The fatal consequences of not treating PTSD

The almost unbearable tragedy reported today of the former soldier David Bradley, who had not been detraumatised from the experience of serving in the Gulf War, Bosnia and Northern Ireland (discharged in 1995), and who killed four members of his family with a pistol before giving himself up to police – reminds me of a short but poignant case study published in the Human Givens Journal in 2003 about a Falklands War veteran who had lived with severe PTSD for over 20 years until being detraumatised in one session using the rewind technique. He describes his experience:

Ken is a 49 year old Falklands veteran who, between March and June 1982, experienced three terrifying events. A missile hit HMS Antelope, but did not immediately explode. Twenty four hours later, it exploded. Ken had to pull bodies out of the water as he was helping to get his colleagues off the ship.

Ken rated his wellbeing, as a result of these events, as 5 out of a possible 50. He described his life before rewind: “I don’t go to parties because of the noise. I know the balloons will bang. I pre-empt by ducking under a table. I start to sweat; it’s sheer terror for me — it takes me back to the war. I vomit — people think I’m drunk or on drugs. I feel I am back on board; I’m swaying.

“I have lain on the bathroom floor for hours because I feel so physically sick. For days I am on edge, sometimes unable to walk. I avoid sleep because of the nightmares and, after several days, I get hallucinations, I sit in the flat in total darkness for days, curtains drawn. I imagine the bus going by is a jet. The smell of fuel oil, ‘burnt pork’ makes me feel sick. I’m sweating profusely but I am cold and shaking, in a state of mental confusion.

“I was like a zombie, a robot. I saw my GP in 1983, after leaving the navy. I saw a psychiatrist for a year. It did not help; it was a waste of time. I have no recollection of what they said, apart from being told I was a manic-depressive. Medication did not stop the nightmares. I have been prescribed Valium, Mogadon, antidepressants and I’ve been given antipsychotic drugs, and they did not help.”

Seven to 10 days after rewind, he said, “The memories don’t seem to bother me anymore. I’m not fearful. I’m unsure — it’s like bereavement. I’ve had 20 years of a wasted life. It’s like coming in to the light. I felt jolly, joking and then — but what am I going to ‘do with it’? I feel all over the place. I feel like I’m born again at 50.”

Three to six months later, he commented, “I feel my face has changed. The light has come on from within; it’s a spiritual light. I am more relaxed, more at peace. I think I am content. I have laughed more in the last weeks than the last 20 years. I sleep much better; I eat well; I can relax. I feel much more in control. This has been life changing for me — no more flashbacks or nightmares; it was like a prison sentence. My partner has noticed the difference in me. She likes what she sees.”source

The surviving family of David Bradley released a statement saying “My sister and I try to cope with this by trying to believe it was not David who did this unspeakable crime but some other entity that slowly took him away from reality and into some other dark world.”

PTSD indeed strips away reality, leaving suffered ‘trapped’ in a world of heightened emotional arousal, so Bradley was in ‘some other dark world’, and the charges against him were rightly dropped under grounds of diminished responsibility due to’ mental illness’.

It breaks my heart to read about the terrible consequences that can arise from people not being effectively detraumatised after horrific experiences (not just soldiers) – so if you know anyone suffering from PTSD or panic attacks please read this article published in the Human Givens Journal (2005) which decribes how the rewind technique, eye movement desensitisation reprocessing (EMDR), and emotional freedom therapy EFT or ‘tapping’) share a common mechanism that explains their often miraculous effects on traumatised people, and also explains why the rewind technique in particular is taught to and used by human givens therapists to great effect.

Posted by: Eleanor


5 responses to “The fatal consequences of not treating PTSD

  1. This is so true. It is wonderful to have people identifying and addressing this issue. In my own experience I found groups that helped and references that helped me piece together a solution for my own situation. Keep up the good work and discoveries!

  2. Careful on the cures! This is highly dangerous with anyone who has PTSD from multiple traumas. I know; I tried EMDR and now have permanent damage. I was not forewarned that EMDR has not been fully tested and the effects on multiple trauma cases is almost unknown. This is just like all the new “wonder” drugs that hit the market. It’s advertised as curing your illness and 20 years later the company finally will fess up that it wasn’t fully tested and/or the adverse effects were ignored. This is no different. I think it’s shameful how this is portrayed without giving the full picture and ignoring the risks to someone’s health and long term effects.

    Becca ( A PTSD sufferer)

  3. I think you will find the same applies to the rewind technique at present. I have found no literature outlining a sound evidence base for any of the topics discussed in Human Givens, and I can’t help thinking there is an element of the pot calling the kettle black.

    Instead I have encountered quite hostile and aggressive individuals who don’t appear capable of having an intellectual open debate on any topic.

    I don’t think its the approach itself that is beginning to seem off putting, more than the defensive nature of the individuals presenting it.

  4. Hi Anna thanks for your comment. I’m sorry to hear that you have enountered that sort of behaviour – there will be no hostility from me – and I am always open to questions, comments and debate.

    Did you read the article by Joe Griffin on exactly why the rewind technique is effective?

    It is crucial to fully understand the rewind technique before making any judgements on it as each step in the rewind process has been put in place for a reason, with the safety of the client at the forefront.

    All human givens therapists are taught the rewind technique through demonstrations (thousands of people have been detraumatised in front of students on our workshops) and by trying it out themselves under strict supervision until they are deemed suitably able to practice the technique in their work.

    You can read more about the rewind technique, from a company who uses it, here:

    Collated results from ongoing IES-E measures for trauma from the red poppy company can be seen on this page:

  5. Hi, Eleanor. I became interested in the article by Joe Griffin that you mention, but the link to it don´t seem to work anymore…soo…I googled it, and found it here:
    thanks a bunch…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s